Gove vs Balls: seconds out!

Image

Statisticians have rushed hither and yon to umpire the row between Michael Gove and Ed Balls in the Commons over whether – as Mr Gove claimed – only 45 of the 80,000 children eligible for free school meals get to Oxford and Cambridge.

Mr Balls said he was wrong, because he hadn’t included those who go on to further education colleges. But the umpires (Kathy Newman’s Fact Check website, and Tim Harford of the Financial Times on Radio 4’s Today programme ) concur that Mr Gove is right.
 
The parliamentary answer that provided the figures is here. In fact, it looks as if Mr Gove on this occasion delivered a googly, if we can change the sporting metaphor. He’s previously asked why only 189 children on free school meals get three A-levels at A grade – and those figures do exclude FE colleges.
 
But the university entrance ones include them, so Mr Balls fell into a well-prepared trap. The figures show, incidentally, that decent numbers of these children do make it to university: 100 to Birmingham, 250 to Queen Mary and Westfield, 155 to Salford, 50 to University College London, for example. In all, 10,590 went on to higher education.
 
But the statistics are pretty basic, rounded to the nearest five, so this calculation shouldn’t be relied upon.The real cause for celebration is that so many people are now seeking to check the facts. Politicians are going to have to be more careful that they usually are in the run-up to the election.
 

Back to Blogs